All moments

Prepare your performance review with confidence

Many people feel uneasy before a performance review, even after a good year: What will it be about? Do I have to talk a lot? What if there is criticism? Most of it can be sorted out beforehand.

How do I prepare for my performance review?

Go back over the whole year, including the spring. Pick two or three examples and decide what you want to have said and heard by the end of the conversation. Set aside an hour a few days ahead.

How preparing for a performance review unfolds

A few days before · about an hour

Go through your calendar, notes and emails month by month. Otherwise the spring is barely in view, even though it counts just as much.

Shortly before

On the day

The review

You walk in with examples, a goal and a request

Start your preparation as a reflection

In about 10 minutes you get clear on your goal, where you stand right now and what your options are. What you write stays on your device.

Hard performance review questions and how to answer them

Some questions in a performance review leave you lost for words at first. It often helps to know what your manager needs the answer for. In many companies it ends up in a form, in a meeting with other managers or in pay planning. That’s why a good answer is one they can pass on.

  • “Where would you put yourself on the scale?”

    What’s behind it: The number often goes into the form. If it’s far from your manager’s own rating, that gap is what the conversation will turn to.

    The reflex: Going one level lower to seem modest. You set the anchor low yourself, and a higher rating then has to be defended against your own number.

    How you can answer:

    “I’d say 4. I carried the onboarding on my own from idea to launch, which goes beyond my role. Where do you see me?”

  • “Are you still motivated?”

    What’s behind it: Your manager has noticed something, maybe that you’ve gone quieter in meetings. Often they’re also wondering whether you’ll stay.

    The reflex: A quick “Sure, of course”. That closes the topic, but the impression stays. Or everything comes out at once.

    How you can answer:

    Say honestly how things are, what’s behind it and what would help. “To be honest, less than last year. Since onboarding has been up and running, I’ve been missing work I can grow in. A project of my own in the first quarter would change a lot.” How much you share about your private life is up to you.

  • “How are things going with Jonas?”

    What’s behind it: Either your manager has picked up on something, or they’re collecting input for Jonas’s review. What you say may come up in his conversation.

    The reflex: Playing everything down although there’s friction, or using the moment to get everything off your chest.

    How you can answer:

    Stick to one situation and its effect, and say nothing about his character. “The documentation is often missing at handovers, and then I spend half a day searching. I mentioned it to him once and would like to sort it out with him directly.”

    As a reflection: Feedback for a colleague
  • “What do you make of that?” after a critical rating

    What’s behind it: Your manager is waiting to see how you react. What you say in that minute often stays with them longer than the rest of the conversation.

    The reflex: Defending yourself straight away and listing counterexamples. Or nodding although you see it differently, so the rating counts as accepted.

    How you can answer:

    Ask for an example and take time for your view. “Can you name a situation you’re basing that on? I’d like to look at it properly and come back to you with my view by Friday.”

    As a reflection: Disagreeing with my review
  • “What would your colleagues say about you?”

    What’s behind it: Your manager has often collected feedback from the team already and is checking whether your picture matches.

    The reflex: General praise like “a team player, always helpful”. It sounds as if you don’t know.

    How you can answer:

    Name one strength with an example and one thing others would wish for. “That they can count on me for anything about onboarding. They’d probably have liked me to flag the support handover delay sooner. Have you had any feedback on that?”

  • “Where do you see yourself in five years?”

    What’s behind it: Often the question of whether you’ll stay and whether training or a bigger project is worth investing in you.

    The reflex: “No idea”, or a goal you’d have to leave the company to reach.

    How you can answer:

    Say which direction you want to grow in and what the next step here would be. “I want to take on more responsibility for how we work. Onboarding is up and running, so the next step would be the handovers between teams. For that I’d need the time I currently spend on support.”

  • “Why should we raise your pay?”

    What’s behind it: Your manager rarely decides this alone. They need an argument they can put forward in the pay round.

    The reflex: Arguing from your own needs, such as rent or rising prices, or from what others earn. Neither is easy for them to pass on.

    How you can answer:

    Give them a sentence they can repeat. “Since March I’ve owned onboarding for the whole department. That’s part of the role description for the next level.”

    As a reflection: Asking for a promotion
  • “Is there anything else you’d like to raise?”

    What’s behind it: Usually the last question. What you don’t say now often waits until next year.

    The reflex: “No, all good”, although you’d planned to raise something. At the end of a long conversation, that happens easily.

    How you can answer:

    Announce your topic and stick to one situation. “Yes, one thing about how we work together. In last week’s team meeting you raised the mistake in the customer letter in front of everyone. I’d prefer we discuss things like that one-to-one.”

What you can say, and what you don't have to

Most worries before a review come down to the same few questions.

What you can say

  • Can I say that I'm unhappy?

    Say what's behind it and what would help. "Since the summer I've been missing work I can grow in" moves the conversation further than "I'm unmotivated".

  • Can I bring up pay?

    Mention the topic in advance so there's time for it, and bring examples that show how your work has changed. Some companies discuss pay in a separate meeting. If yours does, ask when it is.

  • Can I raise criticism of my manager without getting into trouble?

    Yes, with some risk

    You can keep the risk small: talk about one specific situation, what it did to you and what you are asking for. If you are worried about consequences, talk to an employee representative first.

    As a reflection: Criticising my manager

What you don't have to say

  • Do I have to talk a lot?

    Prepare two or three points you will raise no matter what, and let the rest come. Listening and asking questions count just as much.

  • Should I criticise myself?

    One point is enough

    One thing that didn't go well shows that you look at your year honestly. Say what you took from it. You don't need to bring a list of your weaknesses.

  • Do I have to respond to everything on the spot?

    You can say: "I'd like to look at this properly and get back to you by Friday." Especially with criticism or a rating that surprises you, that's often the better answer. Note down what was said, praise as much as criticism, so you have something to respond to later.

What if I'm worried it's about something serious?

Ask beforehand what the conversation is meant to cover. It's a normal question and often takes a lot of the pressure off. If you feel treated unfairly or your job is at stake, get support from HR, an employee representative or legal advice.

This page doesn't replace legal advice.

As a reflection: Feeling uneasy

Which situation are you in?

A specific case has a reflection of its own. This is how it helps:

  1. Pick a situationThe one closest to yours.
  2. Think it throughYou answer the questions of an established method and write down your thoughts.
  3. Go in clearerYou know what matters to you and what you want to say when the moment comes.

What you write stays on your device.

You are being reviewed

Your own year is the topic: before the conversation, during it and afterwards.

You are writing or giving reviews

For anyone who assesses other people's work, with or without a management title. The preparation steps help on this side of the table too.

You are looking at next year

The review is also about next year: about goals, and about what you want to learn.

Something else around your review?

Find a fitting method with a few questions.

Portrait of Daniel Schmeiß

“No surprises.”

A good review sums up the year for both sides and brings clarity for the next one.

What I would do differently today

I should have started much earlier to write down my goals and results regularly, perhaps once a month. It helps with or without a management title: you go into the conversation better prepared, get more out of it for yourself, and can show your manager more than they expect. And next year's plan builds on something tangible.

Daniel SchmeißMore about Daniel and Reflacto

More background