# Criticizing your manager: how to raise a problem with your boss

*Daniel Schmeiß · 2026-11-15*

In Tuesday's customer meeting, the customer asks whether the new export feature can be ready by the end of the month. Before anyone on the team can say something, the team lead answers: "We can do that."

A developer on the team knows the feature needs at least six weeks. It is the third promise like this in the quarter. After the last two, the team worked late. After the meeting, he tells a colleague at the coffee machine: "She's promising things again without asking us."

He says nothing to the team lead. He doesn't want to come across as someone who isn't pulling his weight.

## Why criticizing your manager is harder

With your own manager, more is at stake than with colleagues: they have a say in your work, your review and your pay. So the worry that criticism will come back to bite you is reasonable.

Staying quiet has a cost too. The next promise is bound to come, and the team works late again. The frustration ends up with the colleague at the coffee machine, who can't change anything. Why criticism should reach the person it is about is the topic of the post [Have you told them yourself?](https://www.reflacto.com/blog/have-you-told-them-yourself)

If it is about harassment, discrimination or threats, or you fear serious consequences, get support first: from the works council, HR or someone you trust.

## What your manager may not see

A manager doesn't see everything their decisions set off in the team. In the customer meeting, the team lead has a customer in front of her who wants an answer. She doesn't see the evenings her team spends catching up afterwards.

The other way round, not all of a manager's goals are visible to the team. Maybe the team lead has already reported the date further up, is measured by customer satisfaction, or has heard that the customer is thinking about switching. If you know what she is after, you can tie your criticism to it. Then it helps her with what she wants to achieve anyway.

If you don't know her goals, ask about them, for example at the start of your conversation or in your next one-on-one:

> "What matters most to you this quarter?"

## Decide beforehand what you want to say

The [SBI model](https://www.reflacto.com/frameworks/sbi) helps with preparing: situation, behavior, impact. Add a request. If you write the four parts down once, you'll have the words ready in the conversation.

**Situation.** Pick the latest case, here Tuesday's customer meeting. You both still remember it well.

**Behavior.** Describe what your manager did without judging it: she promised the export would be ready by the end of the month. "You keep promising things" would be a verdict you would only argue about.

**Impact.** This is where you tie in her goals. If a happy customer matters to her, say what a missed date means for the customer. The team estimates six weeks. If the date doesn't hold, the customer ends up more disappointed than she would have been with a later, realistic date. How to describe a concern in the other side's terms is covered in the post [Speak the language of the people you want to reach](https://www.reflacto.com/blog/speak-the-language-of-the-people-you-want-to-reach).

**Request.** Say what exactly your manager can do differently next time, for example: "Check the effort with us before you commit to a date." She can do that in the very next customer meeting.

## The conversation

Ask for a short one-on-one conversation and say what it is about, so nobody feels ambushed:

> "Do you have fifteen minutes for me this week? I'd like to talk about Tuesday's customer meeting."

In a team meeting, your manager would have to save face in front of others and would be more likely to get defensive.

In the conversation, you bring the four parts together:

> "In Tuesday's customer meeting, you promised the export would be ready by the end of the month. Our estimate is six weeks. I'm worried we won't make the date and the customer will be disappointed. Could we agree that you check with us before promises like that? I can usually tell you the effort the same day."

Then ask how she sees it, and listen. Maybe you learn something you didn't know, and you end up with a different solution from the one you had in mind.

## When your manager gets defensive

Your manager may first explain why she acted the way she did: "The customer would have walked away otherwise" or "You usually manage." Hearing criticism isn't easy for managers either.

You don't have to win the conversation. Stick to your example and avoid "always" and "again". Ask what she needs instead:

> "What would you need from us so you don't have to commit on the spot?"

If you don't get further today, suggest talking again in a few days.

## Afterwards

If you agreed on something, write it down in two sentences, for example in a short message.

Suppose the developer has had the conversation. In the next customer meeting, the customer asks about another feature. The team lead says: "We'll check with the team and get back to you tomorrow." In the afternoon, she asks him about the effort.

When something like that happens, tell your manager. Otherwise the only time she hears about it is when it goes wrong. One or two sentences are enough:

> "Thanks for checking with us yesterday before you gave the customer a date. We could plan calmly, and it felt like our estimate counts."

**Feedback like this tells your manager that her change is landing, and makes her more likely to keep it up.**

## The first step

Think of the situation you want to raise and write down four sentences: when it was, what your manager did, what it led to and what you would like next time. With those four sentences in hand, ask for fifteen minutes.

More example phrases and common questions are on the page [How to Give Feedback to Your Boss](https://www.reflacto.com/decide/manager)

---

Original page: https://www.reflacto.com/blog/raising-a-problem-with-your-manager
